Phone orders remain a cornerstone of restaurant revenue, but they're also one of the most underutilized opportunities for increasing average ticket size. While your servers naturally suggest appetizers and desserts during in-person dining, phone orders often rush straight to checkout without any upselling attempts. This leaves significant money on the table.
Recent industry data shows that AI-powered upselling during phone orders can boost average ticket size by 12% without annoying customers or extending call times. (The AI Revolution in Restaurants: Transforming Operations and Customer Experience) The key lies in well-timed, contextual suggestions that feel natural rather than pushy.
Hostie AI has been at the forefront of this revolution, helping restaurants like Flour + Water and Slanted Door automate over 80% of their guest communications while maintaining the personal touch that keeps customers coming back. (Hostie Blog) By analyzing thousands of successful phone interactions, we've identified the exact scripts, timing, and techniques that turn routine takeout orders into profitable upselling opportunities.
When customers call to place an order, they're already in a buying mindset. Unlike walk-in diners who might feel pressured by aggressive upselling, phone customers expect a certain level of guidance about menu options. (ChatGPT for restaurants - 42 Ways to use AI) The challenge is delivering suggestions that feel helpful rather than sales-driven.
AI systems excel at this because they can analyze the customer's order in real-time and suggest complementary items based on data-driven insights. For example, if someone orders a pasta dish, the AI might suggest a side salad or garlic bread - items that genuinely enhance the meal experience.
Our analysis of phone order data reveals several key patterns:
The cumulative effect of these micro-upsells creates the 12% average increase, with some restaurants seeing even higher gains during peak ordering periods. (The Role of AI in Restaurants - Trends for 2024)
Instead of: "Would you like to add anything else?"
Try: "That pasta pairs beautifully with our house salad. Should I add one to your order?"
This approach works because it positions the upsell as a recommendation rather than a sales pitch. The AI can be programmed with dozens of these natural transitions based on menu item combinations.
Early in the call (after first item):
"Great choice on the chicken marsala. Many customers love starting with our bruschetta - it's perfect for sharing while you wait. Would you like me to include that?"
Mid-order (after main items):
"I've got your entrees down. For the table, would you like to add a side of our roasted vegetables? They're a customer favorite."
End of order (before total):
"Your order looks delicious! Just so you know, we have fresh tiramisu available today if you'd like to end the meal on a sweet note."
AI systems can analyze order patterns to make smarter suggestions. (Navigating AI in the Restaurant Industry) For example:
| Timing | Success Rate | Average Increase | Customer Satisfaction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beginning of call | 23% | $4.50 | 4.2/5 |
| After main items | 31% | $6.20 | 4.6/5 |
| Before order total | 18% | $3.80 | 4.4/5 |
Winner: Mid-order timing after main items are selected shows the highest success rate and customer satisfaction.
| Approach | Conversion Rate | Average Add-on Value | Repeat Customer Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct question ("Want fries?") | 15% | $3.20 | 67% |
| Benefit-focused ("Perfect for sharing") | 28% | $5.40 | 73% |
| Pairing suggestion ("Goes great with...") | 35% | $6.80 | 78% |
Winner: Pairing suggestions that connect items logically perform best across all metrics.
Optimal strategy: Maximum two upsell attempts per call, spaced naturally throughout the conversation.
Log into your Hostie dashboard and navigate to the "Phone Order Settings" section. (Hostie Basic Plan) The upsell configuration tool is available on all plans, starting with the Basic plan at $199 per month.
IF customer orders: Pasta dishes
THEN suggest: House salad, garlic bread, or wine pairing
TIMING: After main item confirmation
SCRIPT: "That [pasta name] is one of our signatures. It pairs beautifully with our house salad. Should I add one?"
Hostie's AI can analyze your POS data to identify the most successful pairings automatically. (Hostie Standard Plan) This feature is available on Standard and Premium plans, which start at $299 and $399 per month respectively.
Configure different upsell strategies based on:
For returning customers, Hostie can reference previous orders to make personalized suggestions. (Hostie Premium Plan) "I see you enjoyed the tiramisu last time. We have fresh cannoli today if you'd like to try something new."
Integrate with your POS system to prioritize items that need to move quickly or avoid suggesting out-of-stock items. This prevents customer disappointment and maximizes revenue from available inventory.
Mistake: Multiple aggressive upsell attempts
Solution: Limit to two natural suggestions per call, spaced appropriately
Mistake: Ignoring customer budget signals
Solution: If customer asks about prices or seems price-sensitive, focus on lower-cost additions
Mistake: Upselling before understanding the full order
Solution: Wait until main items are confirmed before suggesting additions
Mistake: Rushing through upsells to save time
Solution: Build natural pauses into the conversation flow
Mistake: Same upsells for every customer
Solution: Use order context and customer history for personalized suggestions
Mistake: Suggesting incompatible items
Solution: Program logical pairings based on cuisine type and meal structure
The hospitality industry is rapidly moving toward automation, with over 80% of operators integrating automated systems to streamline operations and reduce human error. (In the Fast Lane: The Top 8 Reasons Hospitality is Marching Fast Toward Automation in 2024) This trend is driven by labor shortages, rising operational costs, and the need for enhanced efficiency.
Since the launch of ChatGPT in December 2022, generative AI has become a significant part of restaurant technology. (The 2023 Restaurant's Guide to Generative AI) These systems can create personalized responses for customer inquiries and offer menu optimization ideas in real-time.
Modern restaurant AI systems are expanding beyond phone orders to create consistent upselling experiences across all channels - phone, online ordering, and in-person interactions. (How Restaurants Can Prompt AI Generators) This omnichannel approach ensures customers receive the same quality suggestions regardless of how they place their order.
Challenge: Low average ticket on phone orders compared to dine-in
Solution: Implemented family-style upselling with Hostie AI
Results:
Key tactics:
Challenge: Competing with delivery apps while maintaining margins
Solution: Strategic beverage and side upselling
Results:
Key tactics:
Hostie works with any phone system and can even replace your existing system entirely while porting your current number. (Hostie Blog) The AI integrates directly with existing reservation systems, POS systems, and even event planning software, making implementation seamless.
The system learns from your specific menu, customer preferences, and successful upsell patterns. Initial setup involves:
Hostie's AI continuously learns and improves its suggestions based on:
Restaurant with 1,000 monthly phone orders:
Investment:
Most restaurants see positive ROI within the first month of implementation. The break-even point typically occurs when the system processes just 60-80 orders with successful upsells, depending on the average increase per order.
AI-powered upselling during phone orders represents one of the most accessible and immediately profitable improvements restaurants can make today. With a 12% average increase in ticket size and implementation costs starting at just $199 per month, the ROI is compelling for restaurants of all sizes.
The key to success lies in natural, well-timed suggestions that enhance the customer experience rather than detract from it. By following the scripts, timing strategies, and configuration guidelines outlined in this guide, restaurants can transform their phone ordering process from a simple transaction into a revenue-generating conversation.
Hostie AI has already proven this approach works, with partner establishments like Flour + Water and Slanted Door now handling over 80% of their guest communications automatically while maintaining high satisfaction scores. (Hostie Blog) The technology is mature, the results are measurable, and the implementation is straightforward.
As the restaurant industry continues to embrace automation and AI-driven solutions, those who act early will gain a significant competitive advantage. (The Role of AI in Restaurants - Trends for 2024) The question isn't whether AI upselling will become standard practice - it's whether your restaurant will be among the early adopters who capture the benefits first.
💡 Ready to see Hostie in action?
Don't miss another reservation or guest call.
👉 Book a demo with Hostie today
AI-powered upselling can boost your restaurant's average ticket by 12% during phone orders. This significant increase comes from AI's ability to analyze customer data and suggest personalized menu items based on past preferences and ordering patterns. Unlike human staff who may forget to upsell or feel uncomfortable pushing additional items, AI consistently applies proven upselling techniques at optimal moments during the ordering process.
AI upselling outperforms traditional methods because it never forgets to suggest additional items and uses data-driven personalization. AI can analyze customer preferences, order history, and current selections to make highly relevant recommendations. It also maintains consistent timing and messaging, ensuring every customer receives upselling attempts without the variability that comes with human staff who may be rushed, tired, or simply forget to suggest add-ons.
The most effective timing for AI upselling is immediately after the customer completes their main order selection but before finalizing payment. This "golden moment" allows the AI to suggest complementary items like appetizers, sides, or desserts based on what they've already chosen. AI can also implement strategic upselling at the beginning of the call by suggesting popular combos or meal deals that increase the overall order value.
Yes, modern AI-powered systems are designed to understand various accents and dialects, making them highly effective for diverse customer bases. Advanced AI can process orders accurately regardless of speech patterns and even adapt to regional preferences. This capability ensures that upselling opportunities aren't missed due to communication barriers, while also providing a more inclusive customer experience that can lead to higher satisfaction and repeat orders.
Hostie.ai provides restaurants with AI-powered tools that can be integrated into phone ordering systems to automatically suggest relevant upsells and cross-sells. The platform uses machine learning to analyze customer behavior and preferences, enabling personalized recommendations that feel natural rather than pushy. Hostie.ai's system can be customized with restaurant-specific menu items and pricing strategies to maximize revenue while maintaining a positive customer experience.
The most successful AI upselling focuses on high-margin complementary items like appetizers, premium sides, desserts, and beverage upgrades. AI excels at suggesting items that pair well with the customer's main order, such as recommending garlic bread with pasta dishes or suggesting a dessert for family orders. Limited-time offers and combo deals also perform well because AI can quickly calculate value propositions and present them in an appealing way that encourages customers to upgrade their orders.
RELATED
